Outwintering cows on lowland cuts costs
High wintering costs are making suckler cows uneconomic for
many Scottish hill farms. So an Angus farmer has taken to outwintering
cows on lowland arable ground to reduce inputs and avoid hauling
feed into the hills.
Willie Porter and son James farm three arable units, East
Scryne, West Scryne and Carnegie, totalling 364ha (900 acres),
near Carnoustie, on the Angus coast. They grow barley and wheat
for seed, plus potatoes. They also run 170 Blue Grey suckler
cows (Whitebred Shorthorn bull over Galloway cow), 75 spring
calvers and 95 which calve in autumn. Heifers go to a Limousin
bull, while Charolais bulls are used over the cows.
The spring-calving cows live year-round at the Porter's home
farms, summering on permanent pasture. The autumn calvers,
however, summer 90 miles to the west, high in Glen Lyon – Scotland's
longest glen – at Cashlie, a 3075ha (7600-acre)
hill farm, which peaks twice at more than 3000ft, also owned
by the Porters.
The north and south-facing steep slopes of the glen are differing
land types. One side is mainly grass and heather on peat, the
other also has large areas of heather on peat, but is mainly
grass on limestone schist.
A flock of 1100 North Country Cheviots are permanent Cashlie
residents and share their summer grazing with the 95 autumn-calving
Blue Grey cows and heifers, which are restricted to the high
ground, self-selecting their preferred grazing areas of natural
herbage, including indigenous clover, which thrives up to 2000ft,
says Mr Porter.
Feed and bedding costs for over-wintering upland herds in
such remote and non-arable areas such as Glen Lyon, are profit-busting
negatives. Quality Meat Scotland (QMS) 2007 figures for LFA
Hill Suckler Herds show a net margin loss of £222.41
a cow. Feed, forage and bedding totalled £183.35.
The Porter's arable enterprises provide ample over-wintering
feed and bedding, but the only feed hauled the 90 miles into
Glen Lyon is some hay for the ewes – insurance against
grazing running short.
Instead of hauling large quantities of straw and feed into
Glen Lyon for the cows, they are taken back to the Porter's
coastal farms for calving and over-wintering.
"As soon as cows calve, groups of 32 to 35 are turned
on to stubbles, under-sown with Italian Ryegrass. In early
November each group starts strip-grazing a block of about 2.83ha
(7 acres) of kale, strategically placed on sheltered light
land, close to the sea, with access to dry lying areas," says
Mr Porter. "They also receive ad-lib straw – ideally,
one big bale a day – plus 2kg of home-mix with minerals,
until the bulls are taken out."
Cows and calves remain outside until kale is finished in late
February, when they are housed in the buildings vacated by
the finished, previous year's calf crop. The fields, benefiting
from several months of self-spread manure, are ploughed and
"The health of our cattle is a priority," says Mr
Porter. "The herd is vaccinated for BVD (bovine viral
diarrhoea), a great investment. The only time we see any calf
pneumonia is when we bring cows and calves inside.
"So once the cattle are under cover, we make sure calves
can still get outside through narrowly-open gates, enticing
them out with good silage, placed well away from the building.
This keeps them acclimatised to being outside, avoiding a check
The calves are weaned on 1 May. The bull calves, which are
kept entire, run outside, receiving 2kg of barley mix until
housing on 1 September, when they go on to ad-lib silage and
barley mix, to finish November/December.
Heifers summer naturally until introduced to barley mix in
early September. They are housed in early October to finish
on silage and barley from December to February. Target deadweight
for bulls is 350kg at 12.5-14.5 months. Heifers are finished
at about 280kg at 14-18 months.
Some people regard Blue Greys as old fashioned, hairy little
cows, says Mr Porter. "They are in fact purpose-bred suckler
cows, with hybrid vigour, extremely hardy, healthy and fertile,
with milk capable of rearing and making the most of a quick-growing
Continental-cross calf. They also have tight, non-pendulous
udders with small, neat teats which a newborn calf can get
in its mouth and suck."
Blue Grey heifers are bought annually by Mr Porter, at the
November sale at Newcastleton in the Scottish Borders. Bulls,
both Limousin and Charolais, are bought either privately locally,
or at Perth Bull Sales.
To Mr Porter a good bull is one which will get females in
calf, with calves that will thrive, grow and quickly put on
"I buy from pedigree herds I know and choose my Charolais
bulls for size and scale, consulting the figures for a high
liveweight gain. I also note the calving EBVs, but I've found
that in reality there's no difference."
Bulls go into the cows on 1 December for 10 weeks. "Helped
by the health and fertility of the cows, conception is reliably
above 95%, with almost all calving within the first eight weeks."
Once weaned, the autumn calvers return to their Glen Lyon
summer quarters in early May, where, to avoid competing with
ewes and lambs, they go straight to high grazing, above 1200ft.
Mr Porter's autumn-calving suckler enterprise, with the Angus
arable land benefitting from the muck, and the Glen Lyon sheep
grazing enhanced by being grazed down by cattle, might at first
glance seem a luxury, self-contained, "mixed farming" enterprise,
spread over 90 miles. Certainly it would be extremely difficult
to justify keeping cows year round in Glen Lyon.
However, the principle of keeping cattle on the two different
farm types justifies a closer look, he believes. "If arable
farmers with the facilities, feed and bedding, but no stock,
could work with upland farmers with suckler herds who have
to buy in all, or the bulk of their winter feed and bedding,
it could be beneficial for all concerned," says Mr Porter.
For hill farmers there are few realistic options other than
stock, he says. "Scotland's cattle farmers have long benefited
from a premium for their Scotch beef, thanks to the reputation
and image of suckler beef produced in naturally beautiful places
like Glen Lyon. Yet, sadly, the QMS figures show that without
production-linked subsidies, upland herds struggle to be economic."
If ways cannot be found to keep cattle in the hills, the foundation
of one of Scotland's flagship products will be eroded, with
negative knock-on effects for employment in the many associated
businesses which rely on a thriving beef industry, he adds.